Can I get compensation for energy direct debit errors in the UK?
If your supplier has taken the wrong amount, changed your direct debit without proper notice, or failed to refund you promptly, you may be entitled to a refund, interest, goodwill, and in some cases compensation. Use EnergyPlus to compare whole-of-market home energy deals and switch if your supplier isn’t putting things right.
- Check what you can claim: refunds, apology payments and complaint outcomes
- Get a clear complaint checklist to send to your supplier (and when to escalate)
- Compare UK home energy tariffs whole-of-market and switch in minutes
Home energy only. We’re a comparison service (whole-of-market). Switching is optional; this page is guidance to help you resolve direct debit issues and find better value.
If your supplier won’t fix it, switching can stop the pattern
Direct debit problems often repeat: unpredictable increases, slow refunds, or confusing statements. You can pursue your complaint and still compare new tariffs. EnergyPlus helps you compare whole-of-market home energy options so you can move to a supplier with clearer billing and better support.
Good to know: You can usually switch even if you’re disputing the bill. If you have debt, some suppliers may restrict switching depending on the amount and your meter type. Your new supplier can advise during the process.
Compare energy deals (home) — request your options
Fill in the form and we’ll use your details to help you compare available tariffs. You’re not committing to switch.
What counts as an energy direct debit error?
A direct debit problem is usually either (1) a banking/direct debit process issue, or (2) a supplier billing and customer service failure that leads to the wrong amount being collected. In practice, many complaints include both.
Common direct debit / payment issues
- Supplier takes more than agreed or takes payment twice
- Payment is taken on the wrong date or after cancellation
- Direct debit instruction is set up incorrectly (wrong account/reference)
- Supplier fails to action a requested change (amount/date)
Billing problems that can trigger DD disputes
- Supplier uses estimated reads when you’ve provided readings
- Account is in credit but the direct debit is increased anyway
- Refunds are delayed or not paid despite credit balance
- Tariff/price changes applied incorrectly, or statement is unclear
Separate but related: If your bank took the payment correctly but the supplier’s bill is wrong, you still complain to the supplier. If the direct debit collection itself is wrong, you may also be able to claim an immediate refund from your bank under the Direct Debit Guarantee.
What you can get back (refunds, goodwill and more)
In the UK, “compensation” for energy direct debit errors can mean a few different outcomes. What’s appropriate depends on the cause, the impact on you, and how your supplier responds.
| Outcome | When it applies | What to ask for |
|---|---|---|
| Immediate refund (bank) | A direct debit was taken in error or for the wrong amount/date | Request a refund from your bank under the Direct Debit Guarantee (keep proof) |
| Supplier refund | Your energy account is in credit, or billing error created overpayment | Refund to your bank + confirmation of revised direct debit |
| Goodwill / apology payment | Supplier caused avoidable distress/inconvenience (e.g. repeated mistakes, poor handling) | Ask for a goodwill credit/payment reflecting time, disruption, and escalation needed |
| Reimbursement of costs | You incurred charges (e.g. bank fees) because of the error | Request repayment of documented fees + evidence (statements/receipts) |
| Corrected billing & future prevention | The root issue is readings/tariff/account setup | Correct reads, revised bills, direct debit review, written confirmation |
If you’re unsure which route applies, start by documenting the error and asking the supplier for a written breakdown of how your direct debit was set. If the debit itself is wrong, you can approach your bank for a refund while the supplier complaint continues.
How to complain about an energy direct debit error (UK step-by-step)
A successful complaint is specific: what went wrong, what you want back, and what proof you have. Use the steps below as your checklist.
-
Confirm the error and protect essentials
Check your statement(s), dates and amounts. If the collection is clearly wrong, contact your bank about a Direct Debit Guarantee refund. If money is tight, ask your supplier for emergency support options while the issue is resolved. -
Complain in writing to the supplier
Ask for: (a) a corrected bill or direct debit plan, (b) a refund of overpayment, and (c) reimbursement of any fees and a goodwill payment if applicable. Request a complaint reference number. -
Give a clear deadline and keep a paper trail
Save screenshots, emails, letters, call logs, and dates. If you speak by phone, follow up with an email summarising what was agreed. -
Escalate if the supplier doesn’t resolve it
If you’re getting nowhere, ask for escalation to a complaints team. Where appropriate, you can take the complaint to the relevant independent energy ombudsman service after the supplier has had reasonable time to resolve it or you have a deadlock outcome. -
Consider switching to prevent repeat errors
A new supplier won’t automatically erase a complaint, but it can stop ongoing direct debit mismanagement. Compare whole-of-market deals and choose a tariff that suits your usage and budget.
Tip: When you ask for “compensation”, describe the impact (missed payments, stress, time spent, repeated contacts, fees). Specifics make it easier for the supplier (or ombudsman) to assess a fair outcome.
Evidence checklist (what to gather before you claim)
The more clearly you show the mistake and its impact, the faster it’s usually resolved. Gather what you can—don’t worry if you don’t have everything.
Payment proof
- Bank statement line(s)
- Direct debit notifications
- Date and amount taken
Energy account proof
- Latest bill(s) and tariff details
- Balance showing credit/debit
- Meter reads you provided (dates)
Impact proof
- Any bank fees/charges
- Time spent: call logs, emails
- Missed payments caused by the error
What to write in your complaint (copy/paste structure)
Subject: Complaint — Direct debit error and request for refund/compensation
Account details: [Your account number], [Address], [Postcode]
What happened: On [date], you took £[amount] by direct debit. This is incorrect because [reason].
What I want you to do: (1) Refund £[amount] and confirm the revised direct debit going forward, (2) correct my bill/account records, (3) reimburse £[fees] and consider a goodwill payment due to [impact].
Evidence attached: [bank statement], [bill], [meter readings], [emails/call log]. Please provide a complaint reference and respond in writing.
After you send it, keep all responses. If you later need to escalate, this record makes the process much smoother.
Common mistakes that delay compensation
These are the typical reasons direct debit disputes drag on for weeks. Avoiding them improves your chances of a faster refund and a fair outcome.
Mistakes to avoid
- Only calling—without a follow-up email or letter
- Not stating the exact amount you want refunded
- Not attaching evidence (bank line + bill page)
- Agreeing to a new direct debit without asking for a written explanation
Better approach
- Ask for a complaint reference and written response
- Request a direct debit review with updated meter reads
- Set a deadline (e.g. “Please respond within 10 working days”)
- Keep a timeline: dates, names, outcomes
If your direct debit has jumped: ask the supplier to show the consumption assumptions, unit rates/standing charge used, and how much credit/debit is included. This often reveals a misread or incorrect tariff application.
FAQs: energy direct debit errors and compensation (UK)
Can my bank refund a wrong direct debit?
Often, yes. If a direct debit is taken in error (wrong amount/date or not authorised), you can ask your bank for a refund under the Direct Debit Guarantee. Keep records and still raise the issue with your supplier so the underlying billing or instruction is corrected.
Do energy suppliers have to pay compensation?
Not every error leads to a set compensation amount, but you can request a fair remedy: refund, correction, and reimbursement of fees. Where the supplier’s service handling is poor or the impact is significant, a goodwill payment may be appropriate.
Can I cancel my direct debit while I complain?
You can, but it can create arrears and may complicate things. A better approach is to dispute the incorrect debit, request a direct debit review, and agree a revised amount in writing—unless you’re facing financial hardship and need immediate control. If you cancel, tell the supplier straight away and agree an alternative payment plan.
Will switching affect my complaint?
Switching doesn’t automatically end a complaint about past payments or billing. Keep your evidence and continue the complaint process. Switching can help prevent repeat direct debit problems and may reduce your ongoing costs.
What if my bills were based on estimated readings?
Send up-to-date meter readings (or check your smart meter data) and ask for a recalculation. If the estimate caused the wrong direct debit and you’re owed money, request a refund and a revised direct debit schedule.
How long should a refund take?
It varies by supplier and circumstances, but you should receive clear timescales in writing. If the supplier is delaying without explanation, escalate the complaint and ask for a written timeline and a breakdown of what’s causing the delay.
Need a clean slate? If repeated direct debit errors have affected your trust, comparing whole-of-market tariffs can help you find a supplier with clearer billing and direct debit controls. Use the comparison form to see your options.
Trusted help for UK households
When money is taken incorrectly, you need clarity and quick action. EnergyPlus is a UK comparison service offering whole-of-market access for home energy, with a focus on straightforward choices.
Whole-of-market comparison
Compare available home tariffs and choose what suits your usage and budget.
Plain-English guidance
Know what to ask for: refunds, fee reimbursement and complaint escalation steps.
Switching support
If your supplier keeps getting it wrong, switching can stop the cycle.
What customers say
“The steps made it clear what to ask for and how to word my complaint. I also found a cheaper tariff and switched after getting the billing sorted.”
UK homeowner, direct debit dispute
“My direct debit kept changing. Comparing options helped me move to a supplier with clearer statements and a more stable monthly payment.”
UK household, switched supplier
Testimonials are illustrative of typical outcomes and experiences; results depend on supplier, tariff availability and individual circumstances.
Ready to take control of your energy payments?
Use the form to compare whole-of-market home energy deals. If you’re dealing with a direct debit error, you can still follow the complaint checklist and switch when you’re ready.
Important: This page provides general guidance for UK households and is not legal or financial advice. If you’re in financial difficulty, contact your supplier to discuss support options.
Back to Energy Cost Saving Advice